A year-by-year planning model for converting Traditional IRA dollars to Roth during the gap between retirement and the start of Social Security & Medicare-driven income — when tax brackets and IRMAA tiers are at their most favorable.
Educational planning model — not personalized advice. This optimizer projects federal tax brackets, standard deductions, and IRMAA thresholds forward from the published IRS figures (Rev. Proc. 2025-32 for TY 2026, Rev. Proc. 2026-35 for TY 2027) using the inflation rates you specify. Years through 2027 use the published numbers exactly; later years are projected. Actual future thresholds, IRS rules, ACA subsidy structures, and state tax laws will change. Roth conversions are permanent — recharacterization was eliminated by the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. Coordinate with a CPA or qualified tax advisor before executing any conversion.
How to use this tool: Enter your filing status, expected pension and Social Security income, the balance you want to convert, and your inflation assumptions. The year-by-year table shows how much you can convert each year before hitting either the next federal tax bracket or the next IRMAA premium tier. The lifetime scoreboard at the bottom estimates total federal & state tax cost, projected Roth balance built, and tax savings versus doing nothing.
Adjustable Assumptions
Model Inputs
All amounts entered in 2026 dollars; the model inflates by the COLA and bracket rates below. Adjust any input to recalculate the table instantly.
Filing Status & Domicile
% (FL/TX/NV = 0)
Medicare start year
Rollover IRA (Account You Are Converting From)
USD (2026 EOY)
% annual (in IRA)
% (post-conversion)
USD (0 if none)
Inherited IRA Detail (only if balance > 0)
% annual
drives RMD timing
Pension & Social Security
USD/year, 0 if none
YYYY
USD/year
YYYY
USD/year, 0 if Single
YYYY
% annual
% (max for high-income)
Tax & IRMAA Constraints
% annual
% annual
% annual
divs+gains (NIIT input)
ACA Marketplace (Pre-Medicare Years)
USD/year (PTC)
USD (2-person, 2026)
last year on ACA
Survivor Scenario
first Single-filer year
Year-by-Year Cash Flow
Conversion Capacity, 2027–2040
Each row shows that year's floor income (pension + taxable Social Security + inherited IRA RMD), the room remaining inside the next federal bracket and the next IRMAA tier, and the recommended conversion amount given your strategy choice. Highlighted rows mark transitions in the plan.
IRMAA-free year22% bracket bindingIRMAA tier bindingRecommended Roth conversionInherited IRA RMDACA subsidy at riskRoth balance built
Year / Age
Account Balances (EOY)
Forced Distributions
Floor Income
Conversion Capacity
Recommended Conv.
Total MAGI
Roth EOY
Rollover IRA
Inherited IRA
Rollover RMD
Inh. RMD
Pension
SS Tax.
AGI Floor
Room to 22%
Room to IRMAA T1
⁂
Aggregate Outlook
Long-Range Totals (Through Age 75)
Total Inherited IRA Distributed
—
across the stretch period
Cumulative Conversion Capacity
—
2027–2040 if fully utilized
Pre-SS Conversion Window
—
years before SS turns on
Years to Drain Rollover IRA
—
at recommended pace
Lifetime Scoreboard — Plan vs. Do-Nothing
Federal Tax on Conversions
—
marginal-rate cost over the plan
State Tax + IRMAA + NIIT
—
collateral cost of conversions
Roth Balance Built (EOY 2040)
—
tax-free, no future RMD
Estimated Lifetime Tax Saved vs. Do Nothing
—
heir-stretch + own-RMD scenario
Your selected strategy may cost more than doing nothing.
The lifetime tax model is forecasting that your plan's total cost (federal tax on conversions + state tax + IRMAA + NIIT + ACA loss) exceeds the estimated tax burden of leaving the IRA untouched and taking RMDs at age 75. Common reasons this happens:
Aggressive conversions push into higher brackets than your future RMDs would. If "Eliminate RMDs by Age 75" requires 24% bracket conversions to avoid 22% bracket RMDs, the math doesn't work in your favor.
State tax on conversions is high and won't be recovered. If you're paying 6%+ state tax on conversions today and don't expect to move to a lower-tax state, the conversion tax may permanently exceed what you'd pay later.
The conversion window is too short relative to the balance. Large balances near RMD age need bigger annual conversions, often pushing into premium brackets.
Suggested actions: Try a less aggressive strategy ("Auto: 22%, then IRMAA T1" or "Always Stay Below IRMAA T1"), reduce the rollover IRA balance you're trying to convert, or accept that some residual RMDs are tolerable.
Note: the do-nothing baseline only models IRMAA Tier 1 surcharges. Real-world high-balance RMDs often trigger Tier 2 or Tier 3 (~$2,750–$4,400/yr per spouse extra), and a Roth left to non-spouse heirs grows tax-free through the 10-year stretch — both factors that the baseline understates and that tilt this comparison back toward conversion. This warning is directional, not definitive.
How to Read the Output
Methodology & Planning Notes
22%
Why the 22% bracket is usually the right ceiling
The federal brackets jump from 12% to 22% at $100,800 of taxable income (MFJ, 2026; $104,050 in 2027), then from 22% to 24% at $211,400 ($218,250 in 2027). The 22% bracket is wide — roughly $110K–$114K of room for MFJ — and the marginal step up to 24% is small. Filling the 22% bracket converts dollars at a likely-lifetime-low rate; pushing into 24% rarely beats that math unless future RMDs would push you to 32%+.
IRMAA is a cliff, not a curve
IRMAA premium tiers are step thresholds — crossing one by $1 increases your Medicare premium for the entire year. The 2-year lookback means your 2027 MAGI drives your 2029 Part B & D premium. If you are not on Medicare in the lookback year, IRMAA does not bind. This creates the “free years” the model highlights — typically the years before age 63.
ACA marketplace coverage changes the math
For pre-Medicare retirees on a marketplace plan, every dollar of conversion that pushes MAGI above 400% FPL can cost $1,000+ in lost premium tax credits. When the post-2025 cliff is in effect, this is often a harder ceiling than IRMAA. Turn ACA mode on if you are buying coverage through healthcare.gov or a state exchange.
The widow's tax cliff is real
When one MFJ spouse passes, the survivor files Single from the next year forward — same income, brackets cut roughly in half, IRMAA thresholds nearly halved. For couples with significant pre-tax balances and a meaningful age gap or health concern, aggressive Roth conversions now protect the survivor from a large jump in lifetime tax. Toggle the Survivor Scenario to model this.
Roth conversions are permanent
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act eliminated recharacterization after 2017. Once you convert, you cannot reverse the transaction. Best practice: convert in tranches across the year and pay the tax from a taxable account rather than withholding from the conversion itself — withholding shrinks the amount that lands in the Roth and, if you are under 59½, can trigger a 10% penalty on the withheld portion.
Estimated taxes & safe harbor
A large conversion will trigger underpayment penalties unless you meet a safe harbor: pay at least 110% of last year's total tax (if AGI > $150K) or 90% of this year's tax through withholding or quarterly estimates. The Q4 estimate (due January 15) is usually where conversion tax is balanced — but waiting until then can trigger Q1–Q3 underpayment if the conversion was earlier in the year. When in doubt, work with a CPA on a quarterly schedule.
Eliminate RMDs by Age 75 — how it works
Selecting this strategy backsolves a level annual conversion that would fully drain the Rollover IRA before age 75 (the SECURE 2.0 RMD start age). The math is the standard annuity formula: C = B × g × (1+g)N / ((1+g)N−1), where B is the current balance, g is the growth rate, and N is years remaining until age 75. The model recalculates each year so any year-to-year shortfall (caused by a binding tax ceiling) is made up in subsequent years.
The strategy will not push past the 24% bracket. If the math requires more conversion room than the 24% ceiling allows, the RMD goal cannot be fully met without accepting higher marginal rates — in that case, accept some residual RMDs or extend the strategy with QCDs after 70½.