NorthWind Analytics · The Bosun's Locker
Harvesting gains at 0% — and what a Roth conversion costs you for the same room
Long-term gains and qualified dividends have their own rate schedule, and its first band is zero. A married couple can have real taxable income and still pay nothing on gains realized inside that band. You can sell, pay no federal tax, and buy the same holding back the same day — the wash-sale rule applies to losses, not gains — which resets your cost basis upward for free.
The catch nobody prices. Gains stack on top of your ordinary income. So every dollar of Roth conversion you do pushes a dollar of gain out of the zero band and into 15%. The conversion's real cost is its own bracket rate plus that 15% — and the two strategies are competing for exactly the same room.
Annual figures. Gains and conversions you are considering go in the second row.
Gain you can realize at 0% federal
—
How the zero band is calculated for your figures.
Both want the same bracket room, and the cost depends on what you do about it. Harvest less and the conversion costs only its own bracket rate — but you have given up that much basis step-up. Harvest anyway and the displaced gain is taxed at 15%, so the conversion costs its bracket rate plus 15%. Each figure comes from running the whole return twice.
Total federal tax as you realize more gain, and the rate on each additional slice.
And what it deliberately leaves out.
Stacking. Ordinary income fills the brackets first. Long-term gains and qualified dividends then sit on top of it, and are taxed on their own schedule: 0% up to $98,900 (2026) or $102,100 (2027) of total taxable income for a couple, 15% from there to $613,700 (2026) or $633,600 (2027), then 20%. The zero band is whatever is left of that first ceiling after your ordinary taxable income has taken its share — which is why a conversion and a harvest cannot both have it.
No wash-sale rule on gains. The wash-sale rule disallows a loss when you buy back within 30 days. It says nothing about gains. You can sell at a profit and repurchase immediately, which is what makes harvesting worth doing: the tax is zero and your basis resets upward, so a later sale in a worse year is smaller.
Not modelled. The alternative minimum tax, the qualified business income deduction, carried-forward losses, collectibles and section 1250 recapture at their own rates, the Medicare surcharge two years out, and marketplace health insurance subsidies — all of which a large harvest can disturb. Figures are the published 2026 and 2027 amounts from IRS Revenue Procedures 2025-32 and 2026-35. Educational projection, not advice or a prepared return.